Flipping the Script on Audio Description Part Three – Moving Beyond Just US
Wednesday, November 25th, 2020I’ve had conversations where people have said, Blind users don’t want to know about race, they want it to be completely neutral.
– >Elaine Lillian Joseph
Today we’re going beyond the US border to hear from two international describers. Rebecca Singh of Superior Description Services in Canada.
And if that’s not international enough for you here in the states we have Elaine Lillian Joseph from the United Kingdom.
We hear a bit about their AD origin story or how they came to description, the importance of centering Blind people in the process and more on guidelines for describing race, color or ethnicity.
And by the way, who in the world is neutral? Just US? Hmm!
Maybe not the final episode in the Flipping the Script series, but it is the last of 2020!
Listen
Transcript
Show the transcript
Music Begins – A smooth, funky mid tempo Hip Hop beat
TR:
What’s good Reid My Mind Radio Family!
It’s me, your brother Thomas Reid. I hope you’re doing well.
Me? Why thank you for asking. I am doing well.
Today, we’re bringing you part three of the Flipping the Script on Audio Description series.
You know, this was never actually supposed to be a series. I originally planned for one episode but it was quickly evident that several people had something to share on the subject.
It got me thinking about Audio Description in two categories.
First, mainstream.
These are the writers and narrators creating AD for major television and film projects.
Then you have the independents – these consist of a varying degree of theater, live performance, museum and other sorts of description work.
Flipping the Script is all about promoting different voices, alternative views and Audio Description topics that are often overlooked.
As we’ve seen, this applies to both mainstream and independent.
I can’t say for sure this is the end of the Flipping the Script series but I can say it’s the last for 2020.
You know, just when I think I’m done with the topic…
Audio: “… they keep pulling me back in” Al Pacino in Godfather Part 3
Audio: “And here we go!” Slick Rick, A Children’s Story
Audio: Reid My Mind Radio Intro
Rebecca:
My name is Rebecca Singh I am an Audio Describer also a performer. I’m the owner of Superior Description Services which is an Audio Description service which consults with the Blind and partially sighted community one hundred percent of the time. I am a cisgender woman of color and I live in Toronto Canada with my young family.
[TR in conversation with Rebecca:]
How’d you get involved with Audio Description?
Rebecca:
I got involved with Audio Description through the theater actually. I have been a performer for a very long time and just over ten years ago I saw an audition posting for this thing I’d never really heard about, Audio Description and it was a class that I had to audition to get into. I got the part. Started training, that led to something of a building up of the industry here in Toronto.
— Music Begins – A dance track with a driving beat!
TR:
That’s right Y’all, in this third part of Flipping the Script on Audio Description we’re going international!
What’s that? Canada’s right there to the north? Ok, let’s cross the Atlantic.
Audio: Airplane in flight.
Elaine:
My name is Elaine Lillian Joseph. I’m from a city called Birmingham which is the second biggest city in the U.K. I’m a proud Birmie! I’m a Black woman. I’ve just got my hair done. I’ve got long light brown extensions with cane row on top. I’m wearing a floral long just below the knee length dress. I’m sitting in my friend’s bedroom because I’m currently quarantining with my friend’s family. I’ve been doing AD for just under two years. I work for ITV which is our second biggest channel after the BBC. I’m also a freelance Subtitler so I do subtitles for Hard of Hearing as well. A lot of accessibility going on.
TR:
Subtitling or what we know here in the states as Captioning was Elaine’s gateway to Audio Description.
A fan of film and television, she studied English and German in college — oh my bad, University
Elaine:
It always seemed like a natural thing to want to go into media. Finding out that there was this whole kind of world of accessibility and it’s not just, it’s not just transcription I guess. Not that there’s anything wrong with transcription but that you can be a bit creative with it. Doing subtitles for Hard of Hearing for example, doing a Horror film and working out how to describe the sound of of an alien creature and what words am I going to use to do that. It seemed like a natural transition from that to also thinking about how to describe things in general.
TR:
Prior to working at ITV, Elaine was Subtitling at another firm, BTI. it just so happened to be the employer of an influential colleague.,
Elaine:
Veronica Hicks, who kind of really kick started AD in the U.K., certainly. She used to sit directly behind me and she has this velvety plummy (chuckles) voice. I was sitting subtitling and thinking what is it that she does because it sounds fascinating.
TR:
Elaine asked around and learned more about Audio Description. Eventually she left BTI.
Elaine:
Everybody at my company knew that I really really wanted to do it. A position came up; they kind of said go for it! I tested and I got the job and I’ve been very very happy ever since.
TR:
Such an important thing to keep in mind — let people know you’re interested.
Today, Elaine has written AD for projects including a remake of Roswell. She’s been trained on narration so we can expect to hear her post pandemic. She also narrates live performances.
Elaine:
I usually do kind of Queer Cabaret events. There’s like dance, spoken word, lip syncing and things like that.
— Music ends with a drum solo
[TR in conversation with Rebecca:]
I’m wondering what was the experience from your other work that you brought to Audio Description?
Rebecca:
I liked my drama class in junior high and I decided this is the best thing ever. I made my way to a performing arts high school and got bitten by the performing bug and was doing at first some film and television. As it goes as a performer, the work opportunities change.
Instead of just sitting by the phone as they say, I shifted over to doing more theater work, clowning.
[TR in conversation with Rebecca:]
The whole get up, the makeup and everything? Or is that something different? (Chuckles)
Rebecca:
I think that’s a certain kind of clown. I was living in Montreal, like the city of Circ De’ Sole. It was a little bit more movement, physical theater based kind of stuff. The acrobatic storytelling with the body. I went to dance school for a while. So it was really more about expressing myself through the body.
[TR in conversation with Rebecca:]
Okay, so you’re not jumping out of cars with like fifty other clowns. (Laughs)
Rebecca:
No!
TR:
She’s a creative person who found herself doing more arts administration. After moving to Toronto she moved back into the performance space gaining even more of the experience she needed for Audio Description. That physical performance for example prepared her for her first AD assignment describing physical comedy. And the administration work was quite valuable as it gave her a community of people to talk to or a network.
Rebecca:
There were people that had already worked with me in a different context and so I understood their concerns, what their fears were as producers. Everything from being afraid of touch tours because you’re potentially bringing a service animal onto a stage before the show. Rehearsal schedules, the time and space actors need. The types of conversations that are appropriate to have with directors if you’re having discussions. When is a good time to approach a designer if you have some questions? All of those things really help to mitigate any hesitancy that producers had in terms of adding something new to their palette.
TR:
Elaine’s love of reading & creative writing adds value to her description. But that merging of creativity with Audio Description has it’s challenges.
Elaine:
It’s a service and I think it’s important to remember it’s a service. There can be ego (Chuckles) in any industry and sometimes I think people forget the user and what’s most important to the user.
TR:
Rebecca has her own way of assuring Blind consumers are always centered throughout her process.
Rebecca:
Paid Blind and partially sighted consultants. I get two different kinds of feedback. I learned a long time ago it’s definitely not a one size fits all in terms of description. I have a roster of consultants with different interests as well. I also try to match the interests of the consultant. Some people like Opera, some people like dance. All of their different expertise filters into my descriptions. And they ask those really deep and probing questions that I have to find answers to.
[TR in conversation with Rebecca:]
What kind of differences do you find between the Blind and partially sighted feedback that you get?
Rebecca:
One of the most striking differences is things like when I’m describing a set. With people who are partially sighted some people need to sit really really far up close and they want a different type of perspective in terms of what the set looks like. they may not be sitting in the same place. If they have a service animal they may be sitting further back in the theater. Maybe they’re closer to a speaker where that might cause some sound level things that need to be worked out. Sometimes light matters in a production, sometimes it doesn’t. Sometimes I’ll get feedback from Blind consultants saying things like I really appreciated the fact that you called this thing almond shape because I know what an almond feels like. I really developed a sense of what words work better and what words are more inclusive over time working with both Blind and partially sighted consultants especially if they’re working together with me on the same show.
That’s the other benefit of having multiple consultants is that they can learn from one another and I always have a chance to bring in somebody new and widen my pool.
TR:
Inclusive language reflects all sorts of identities.
Elaine:
I’ve had conversations with people before about things like race. It’s wonderful that we’re kind of having a moment where we’re really grappling with that. And I’ve had conversations where people have said, Blind users don’t want to know about race, they want it to be completely neutral. I find that a really interesting argument because I’m like what does neutral actually mean and who are we assuming is neutral?
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
How do those conversations come up when writing description?
Elaine:
When I first started I remember asking questions like should I describe color? Should I describe that this rose is red or that this car is blue or whatever? And then moving from that I guess to should I describe race and the color of somebody’s skin?
So I’ll talk specifically about race rather than diversity I guess because there are other things that we can describe.
The industry standard was to not describe race unless it’s important to the plot.
TR:
By now, if you’ve been following this ongoing conversation on the podcast, you should be pretty familiar with this AD guideline.
As an example of the guideline, Elaine refers to a production of Hamlet
Elaine:
And Hamlet is Black. Then I should mention it. But that doesn’t mean I should mention the race of anybody else. We can assume that everybody else is white. I took that on board and then I kind of ignored it a little bit. (Laughs)
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
(Laughs…)
Elaine:
Because I just found it really difficult. I was like, but why? (Laughs)
I found that I was working on shows where I just wanted to describe like the color of somebody’s skin.
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
Why?
Elaine:
Why!
Because I thought, what’s it mean for it to be relevant to the plot. If there’s a conversation happening between sighted users and they’re saying oh did you notice how the policeman in whatever show it is is Black? I just kind of feel that means that as a Blind user you can’t be part of that conversation because someone’s decided that that Black policeman isn’t relevant to the plot so we’re not going to mention them. Also personally I know Blind users who I’m friend’s with who definitely wanted that information to be included because they’ve definitely felt like there are conversations that they can’t be part of because people are making these decisions.
TR:
Decisions being made on behalf of Blind people without our input. How does that make you feel?
Elaine:
Initially I wasn’t bold enough to say the Black man. I would describe the texture of his hair. So I would say the man with black afro textured hair. (Laughs) I think it should be fairly clear, but I still felt like I was kind of skirting around it.
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
Would you get any pushback?
Elaine:
We definitely didn’t receive any pushback. When my manager kind of reached out to a community of Blind users then it was an overwhelming yes! (Chuckles) Please do include that.
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
Okay. So you never got pushback from management.
Elaine:
No. My immediate manager was like a resounding yes! When I went into the kind of wider Audio Describer community that’s where I definitely felt pushback.
TR:
Like the time Elaine attended a conference where for the first time she heard a discussion of race and Audio Description included in the conversation.
Elaine:
There was a lot of why do we need to do this? What terms do we use? People not feeling comfortable saying the Black man – will the terms change. We might offend somebody, so it’s better if we don’t use any terms at all and just kind of ignore race. It felt uncomfortable for me being the only Black person in the room.
TR:
That’s uncomfort when people are either looking to you for the answer. Or one that I know I’ve experienced, giving the impression that you’re doing something wrong by raising the issue. (Oh well!)
Elaine:
Maybe it’s my British politeness kicking in but I found it very difficult to sit and listen to kind of put in my two pence. Imagine if a user is Black, maybe they do want to know about race (laughs… You never know!
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
Yeh, absolutely
It’s just as important for a Blind consumer who is not Black to know that there are Black people on the screen y’all, like this is real.
Elaine:
Definitely.
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
I’m wondering if there’s an age gap here too. Is this the old guard that we’re talking about here?
Elaine:
I guess so, yes.
I have much respect for them. I feel like I need to put that disclaimer out . (Chuckling)
I really do and I felt like almost a young usurper at that conference and in some of these conversations I’ve had. I get that they’ve been trained in a specific way. If we look at the breakdown of describers in the U.K. it’s white middle age women.
Audio: “To be or not to be. That is the question” From Hamlet, Royal Shakespeare Company
Music ends with beat in reverse!
Rebecca:
I feel like I owe it to the listener and the listener is not necessarily a middle class cisgender white female or a male and sometimes I feel like from some of the teaching and reading and some of the history from what I’ve seen of Audio Description and words, it’s really taking one particular perspective. That is exclusionary and also not fair to people who are Black and Indigenous or people of color.
TR:
In general, no matter what country, fairness, access, equity that should be the goal.
Rebecca, who thinks quite critically on this subject of inclusion presented at a conference in Europe.
Rebecca:
The Advanced Research Seminar on Audio Description.
I, over the last, I would say five years or so, have been really been honing in on the idea of creating the Canadian accent for Audio Description. We here have had a lot of influences from England and also from the states. We haven’t had our own Audio Description culture in Canada. So I went and was the first person to present from Canada and I talked about creating the Canadian accent and describing race gender, class and recognizing our bias.
[TR in conversation with Rebecca:]
And how was that received?
Rebecca:
people were very interested. I think that there’s not a practice of using consultants quite as much as we do here in North America and specifically what I do. The other thing that was really well received was the fact that I presented it in a way that did not require any description. I described all of the images. I tried to make the entire experience inclusive to a point where the person who was operating the CART, the real time captioning, didn’t have anything to write. That was all just part of the example of how we can be more inclusive.
TR:
The responsibility of making media inclusive and accessible includes the role of Audio Description.
Rebecca:
Everybody deserves the opportunity to see themselves in a story. We as people who are helping to tell a story have a responsibility to do everything that we can to not exclude people from seeing themselves.
TR:
So what exactly does that responsibility include?
Rebecca:
even as Describers we need to understand what our own bias is. I live in a very progressive city. And I live in a arts bubble inside that city. I try and check myself against that as well. I don’t want to use language that is so open that only a very small amount of people with very specific references will understand.
We need to have more conversations with consultants and also understanding what the history is and what the perspective is of people who are heavy users of Audio Description. We need to talk about it.
TR:
She’s talking about multiple conversations from all perspectives. Some times that just means raising the issue.
Rebecca:
It’s all of those little tiny actions that every person can do just to point out when things could be better perhaps or when things could be more inclusive.
Just being self-reflective about how we’re receiving information. I think many voices is much better as opposed to a government mandate or something like that.
Sometimes words aren’t enough.
TR:
But the words can inspire actions that lead to real change. Like getting film makers and broadcasters to include a bit more space to allow for Audio Description.
Ultimately, the change happens when our thought process becomes more inclusive.
Rebecca:
If the creator of the material no matter what it is, has the Blind and partially sighted community in mind as part of their audience from the beginning.
TR:
Having Blind people in mind translates to our access not being an afterthought. When it comes to Audio Description?, we need to be centered.
[TR in conversation with Rebecca:]
So the idea that there are sighted people enjoying Audio Description?, that’s cool, that’s really cool and I get it because hopefully that means there will be more of it, right?
Rebecca:
Yeh!
[TR in conversation with Rebecca:]
Do you see the potential for that to be a problem?
Rebecca:
I’m really in favor of Audio Description guidelines and standards being created for the needs and wants of the Blind and partially sighted community. Anyone who is putting something forward that they call Audio Description is aware of these guidelines and is providing something that is standardized. That said I think it’s also okay to create things that are not necessarily Audio Description?, but use techniques of Audio Description and as long as they’re not called Audio Description. I think more is better and so as long as it’s not called Audio Description when it doesn’t meet the standard, go for it!
TR:
From my understanding, there are conversations happening today exploring these guidelines.
I’m not sure what will end up being decided, but I do know that if these conversations do not include people of color in a real way, including decision makers, then we have to ask the question, why? Is it just fashionable right now to appear as though we’re addressing issues of diversity?
It’s a similar question I asked of all those in the Flipping the Script series;
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
It’s a simple question, so feel free to answer (laughs) because I’m asking it!
Elaine:
(Laughs) I see I have no choice. (Laughs) Okay!
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
(Laughing )No, but answer it anyway you want.
My question is why, why AD?
Elaine:
Oh! That’s a lovely question.
AD has brought me into contact with people that I probably would have never have met. In terms of the Queer drag community that I’m now part of and speaking to Blind users and Blind performers as well. I think that’s enriched my life and I hope that the descriptions I give in turn enrich their experience.
Last year I remember telling someone another sighted person, that I did AD. They just laughed and were like Blind people don’t watch TV. That was just like a whole education let’s just say for that person. (Chuckles)
I think it’s a really, really beautiful service and I think that it’s having a bit of a moment over here where people are certainly from the describer point of view, people are starting to think about how we can change it and engage even further with the community who uses it and that’s really, really exciting to be part of honestly. It’s so so fun! I honestly want to keep on doing this and developing my skills and my confidence and listening to people.
— Music begins – a chill piano leads into a smooth jazz chill Hip Hop beat
Rebecca:
I am a storyteller, I was born that way (chuckles). I think it’s really important to be able to tell your story in a way that everyone can hear it, receive it. I don’t think we have any excuses to ignore that anymore. We have technology to help us out. I want to see the amazing wonderful gifts that actually like Blind and partially sighted creators present having had access to some of this more popular culture. Some kind of performance art. So I think it’s important for everybody to have those opportunities. and I really feel like access to art is as important as access to sport. I think it’s part of what makes us human. And so everybody should have this access.
I just think it’s fair!
TR:
That’s Rebecca Singh, you can call her CEO of SDS or Superior Description Services where she centers Audio Description.
Rebecca:
Also known as described Video here. I do live description, image description, I produce podcasts with the Blind and partially sighted community in mind. Consultation to help with Universal Design. My Twitter handle is @SDSDescriptions.. I’m also on Face Book Superior Description and you can always check me out at SuperiorDescription.com.
TR:
Elaine Lillian Joseph is on Twitter @@elaineLJoseph.
I’d like to thank Elaine for putting up with my attempt to include the London slang in our conversation.
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
Init! (Hysterical laugh)
Elaine:
(Laughs) Oh my days, you really love Top Boy don’t you?
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
I do!
I get in to the whole street shows and all that type of thing so, I’m sorry! it’s Hip Hop I’m going to be in there!
Elaine:
Ah, that makes you (possibly says me) really happy! I love it, I love it!
[TR in conversation with Elaine:]
Yeh! (Laughs)
TR:
Big shout out to Rebecca and Elaine for all they do and for openly sharing their experience and opinions for the improvement of AD for all.
So let me welcome you to the Reid My Mind Radio Family!
Audio: Air horn!
I’m hoping you’ll hear them back on the podcast in the future.
While this is the last official episode of 2020, you know I usually do something for the holiday season. Right now at the time of this recording, I have no idea what that is, but I’m pretty sure I’ll put something together to wrap up this incredibly challenging year.
To be sure you get that episode;
Subscribe wherever you get podcasts!
Transcripts & more are over at ReidMyMind.com. And let me do a bit of Audio Description for you. That’s R to the E I D
(Audio: “D and that’s me in the place to be” Slick Rick)
— Music Ends
Like my last name.
Audio: Reid My Mind Outro
Peace!
Hide the transcript